When Your Sleep Aid Becomes a Dream Hijacker
Why melatonin turns some creative minds into unwilling participants in nightly cinema.
Update on Interviewing Claude (AI). The first “conversation” happened spontaneously. Now, I’ve put my professional research cap on and considered many of the comments I received. I will post the second part of the series next week: AI Meditations & Hallucinations. In the meantime, I appreciate you supporting me through likes and comments - it means a lot to me!
The “Natural” Sleep Aid That Keeps You Awake
You've heard it a million times: melatonin is gentle, natural, safe. It's basically sleep in a bottle, right?
Wrong—at least for some of us.
One evening you take what's supposed to be nature's own sleep remedy, then spend the night trapped in hyperactive dreams that feel like someone cranked your subconscious up to eleven. You wake up more exhausted than when you went to bed, wondering what went wrong with this "harmless" supplement.
If you're creative, intuitive, or someone who already experiences rich dream life, you might be part of a small but significant group for whom melatonin doesn't just fail—it actively backfires. You wake to discover you've been riding around on the Magical Dream Bus all night with a jacked-up driver!
What's Really Happening in Your Brain
Here's what most people don't realize: melatonin doesn't just make you sleepy. Studies have found that melatonin can increase REM sleep, the sleep cycle known for causing vivid dreams. When you're spending more time in the stage where dreams happen, you're basically giving your brain extended screentime for its nightly movie marathon.
The problem? Some brains are already producing Oscar-worthy content without any chemical assistance.
Higher doses—that is, 5 milligrams at a time—can lead to dizziness, headaches, and nausea, and some people may experience changes in blood pressure, vivid dreams, or nightmares. But even standard doses can trigger what I call "dreams on a double espresso" for certain people.
Your Creative Brain Might Already Be Optimized
Recent neuroscience research reveals something fascinating about creative minds. The ability to generate creative ideas is characterized by increased functional connectivity between the inferior prefrontal cortex and the default network, pointing to a greater cooperation between brain regions associated with cognitive control and low-level imaginative processes.
A creative brain already has enhanced cross-talk between different regions. Highly creative people are characterized by the ability to cooperate between cortical hubs within default, salience, and executive systems—intrinsic functional networks that tend to work in opposition.
In other words, some brains are like a standard stereo system. Creative brains are like high-end sound systems with multiple speakers already perfectly calibrated. Adding melatonin is like cranking up the volume on equipment that's already running at optimized levels—you get distortion, not better performance. But there is more to it, however, than being a particularly creative person who ends up with off the charts dream experiences.
The Genetic Wild Card
Here's what I find interesting. Your reaction to melatonin might be written in your DNA. A potential relationship has been implicated between predicted slow-metabolizing alleles in CYP1A2 and susceptibility to sleep problems, with the hypothesis that effectiveness disappears because of slow metabolization of melatonin due to single nucleotide polymorphisms of CYP1A2... and yeah, I had to read that sentence about five times too.
In plain English: some people's genetic makeup makes them process melatonin differently. If you're a slow metabolizer, the supplement hangs around in your system longer, potentially amplifying those vivid dream effects. This is why you can be a creative, intuitive individual and be able to take melatonin, and others end up on the magical dream bus.
When Dreams Turn into Cinema Verite
By increasing the amount of time spent in the stage of sleep when most dreaming happens, melatonin may allow more time for people to experience nightmares. But for highly creative individuals, it's not just about more dreams—it's about more intense, bizarre, and sometimes disturbing dreams.
This intensity goes beyond just having more dreams—especially if you're someone who's naturally tuned into subtle internal processes.
Why Your Intuitive Side Rebels
If you consider yourself highly intuitive, you might notice that melatonin doesn't just disrupt your sleep—it seems like it's interfering with something deeper. That's not woo-woo thinking; it's biology.
Melatonin affects the pineal gland, often called the "third eye" in various traditions. For people who are already sensitive to subtle internal processes or who have naturally active dream states, adding synthetic melatonin can feel like forcing extra fuel into an engine that's already running smoothly.
The Individual Difference That Medicine Ignores
Here's the thing mainstream sleep advice won't tell you: just because something works for most people doesn't mean it's right for your particular chemistry. Genetic polymorphisms influence CYP1A2 activity, with slow and fast metabolizer phenotypes reported based on chemical metabolism in human liver preparations. Yeah, another one from the research papers.
Your creative wiring, your natural dream patterns, your genetic makeup—all of these factors create a unique neurochemical profile that might make melatonin counterproductive rather than helpful.
Whether you take melatonin or not, there are very good lifestyle fixes that will promote a more restful night's sleep.
What to Do Instead
Work with your existing rhythms. Your vivid dreams and active inner life aren't bugs to be fixed—they're features of how your brain operates.
Focus on sleep hygiene that doesn't involve supplements. Cool rooms, consistent bedtimes, and limiting screens before bed work with your natural chemistry instead of against it. Develop a soothing routine for bedtime, and turn your worries over to a higher authority for the night.
Consider that your "sleep problems" might not be problems at all. Creative minds often have different sleep patterns, though this doesn't mean non-creative people have inferior sleep patterns—everyone's brain has its own optimal rhythms. What looks like insomnia might actually be your brain's optimal operating schedule.
Trust your body's feedback. If a "natural" supplement makes you feel worse, that's valuable information about your individual biology.
The Bigger Picture
This melatonin example should warn you about messing with your brain chemistry, especially when your brain's unique wiring—the same wiring that contributes to creativity, intuition, and rich inner experiences—can make you respond differently to substances that other people swear by. Your DNA can be an independent variable as well.
The goal isn't to change how your brain works, but to understand and support its natural patterns—whether you're highly creative, analytically minded, or somewhere in between. Sometimes the best interventions are lifestyle adjustments.
Thanks for Reading! Remember all the jazz … sharing is caring! Comments too. They help me develop better and more focused content. Most often my content ideas come from questions I get on social media, but since you are a subcriber or follower, I’d rather give your questions top priority!
References:
Healthline. "Melatonin Dreams: Does Melatonin Cause Vivid Dreams?" February 25, 2020. https://www.healthline.com/health/sleep/melatonin-dreams
Cleveland Clinic. "Can Melatonin Cause Bad Dreams? What Experts Say." August 6, 2021. https://health.clevelandclinic.org/does-melatonin-cause-bad-dreams
Sleep Foundation. "Can Melatonin Cause Nightmares?" November 16, 2023. https://www.sleepfoundation.org/melatonin/can-melatonin-cause-nightmares
Well+Good. "Can a Melatonin Habit Cause Nightmares or Vivid Dreams? Short Answer: Yes." November 11, 2022. https://www.wellandgood.com/lifestyle/melatonin-nightmares
Beaty RE, Benedek M, Silvia PJ, Schacter DL. "Creativity and the default network: A functional connectivity analysis of the creative brain at rest." Neuropsychologia. 2016;64:92-98. PMC4410786
Neuroscience News. "The Creative Brain is Wired Differently." January 23, 2018. https://neurosciencenews.com/creativity-networks-8355/
Melke J, Goubran Botros H, Chaste P, et al. "Genetic variation in melatonin pathway enzymes in children with autism spectrum disorder and comorbid sleep onset delay." J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry. 2014;53(11):1234-43. PMC4289108
Braam W, Ehrhart F, Maas AP, et al. "CYP1A2 polymorphisms in slow melatonin metabolisers: a possible relationship with autism spectrum disorder?" Med Hypotheses. 2012;79(3):275-81. PMID: 22823064
Sciencedirect Topics. "CYP1A2 - an overview." https://www.sciencedirect.com/topics/agricultural-and-biological-sciences/cyp1a2
The information provided on this blog is intended for general informational and educational purposes only. It is not intended to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment.
hey many people can't sleep! I am lucky not to have those issues. Thanks for providing valuable insight on this subject that is most critical to human wellness.